This June, we saw a monument to Obama-era optimism laid down, in a hieroglyphical tomb, twenty years after it was born in Hyde Park. There was a buzz all summer, as pilgrims flocked to the Obama Presidential Center to tour its grounds and pay their respects to the Obama legacy. The monument, which resembles four hands reaching up into the sky, advertises itself as a “place of dreaming,” and the messages of stubborn hopefulness are so strong that one gets the sense if they just paid their thirty dollars and climbed all the way up to “the Sky Room,” it might fist-bump them back into the 2010s. But it’s a strange feeling to walk through our childhood political imagination as a museum, and experience the aesthetics of a colorful, triumphalist liberalism as… a little retro.
Venting this discomfort in a sneering critique is easy; we’ve called the building soviet or fascist, spread rumors that there are spelling mistakes in the facade, and written op-eds about how it looks like a trash can or the spaceship from Arrival. But it’s harder to articulate why these images—of monumental upwardness, commodified diversity, or blank-slate future-mindedness—feel outmoded. It is certainly partly for political reasons: the opening of the Obama Center has increased short-term rental leases for companies like Airbnb by 46 percent in the South Shore area and has prompted disputes around the Obama Foundation’s refusal to sign a Community Benefit Agreement to protect local residents from price increases and investor speculation. The center is also not a presidential library because Barack Obama wanted his foundation to control the grounds—so it actually contains no federally operated presidential records. But the most interesting question for me is the aesthetic one. That is, how did the genuine anxieties, unconscious desires, and kernel of utopianism of that time fall into vacant visual clichés?
In other words, there’s a double bind: we feel a nostalgic attachment to a scene of possibility, and also a friction in the shifting meaning of a certain set of hardened, comfortable symbols. In Cruel Optimism, Lauren Berlant tells us that this awkward relationship with an outmoded cultural object is actually productive: “to see what is halting, stuttering, and aching about being in the middle of detaching from a waning fantasy of the good life” is actually what allows us to deconstruct a false hope in the present. Feeling our non-identity with the ‘Obamalisk’ is the first step toward creating a richer way of historicizing what is affectively felt, but still unnamed, about that recent history.
A few blocks down the Midway, a gallery show called Longer Than the Sky: Art of the Obama Years, curated by Jenny Harris, lays bare a people’s history of the Obama years. The show, on view at the Logan Center from July to October, took its title from a James Baldwin short story, “Sonny’s Blues,” in which a man watches his talented blues musician brother fall into addiction. At the end of the story, Sonny plays a piece on the saxophone so beautiful that the narrator thinks freedom lurks around them all. But the hope is ephemeral, and he is soon “aware that this was only a moment, that the world waited outside, as hungry as a tiger, and that trouble stretched above us, longer than the sky.” In her press release, Harris explains that this story “evokes the intermingling of optimism and despair” that defined 2008–2016. The show is organized into six distinct themes, each of which contains an oblique political critique in which “hope and change” are inflected with anxiety and continuity. Together, these parts present a political history which routes the normative Obama narratives through the naked material experience of their time; it addresses the commodification of racial identity, the financialization of the public sector post-2008, the internet spectacle of gun violence, and the endurance of Wars on Terror in the Middle East.
In contrast to the imposing immediacy of the Obama Center, Longer Than the Sky is a show about the aesthetics of mediation, or the way that artworks draw attention to the distance between object and viewer. Artists performing a variety of political interventions all seem to need this tool, because layered images attune us to the way American culture became used to seeing at this time. They evoke an unnamed feeling of the 2010s the Center can’t seem to access. The representations of mediated experience get increasingly abstract until, by the end of the show, there are artworks that use this tool to visualize historical time itself. Whereas the Obama Center has tried to simply drop an old political paradigm back in our community, four works from Longer Than the Sky demonstrate another way of historicizing: using art to show us how we’ve changed.
One of the first pieces in the show is a photograph by Catherine Opie of Obama’s first Inauguration ceremony on the National Mall. The print shows a scattered group of people winding through fences at the Capitol, all faced away from the camera, in bright-colored puffer coats on a grey day. Each observer has their arms crossed or hands on their hips, looking up towards a huge screen displaying the Obamas waving at the crowd in lagging time. In the background, there are lines of more fences organizing more people supporting more TVs trailing more electrical wires—all reproduced in a Borgesian hall of mirrors on each screen. Opie’s work often features clashing public and private spaces; in the inaugural photo, each observer has a serialized displayed experience of what is supposed to be one public event. Standing in the gallery with our hands on our hips looking at a photograph the size of a flat-screen, any viewer becomes another member of this observing crowd, at one more degree of physical and temporal separation from Obama’s inauguration. Paradoxically, this representation of removed experience makes us feel implicated, perhaps because we experience so much of political lives online.
Rachel Harrison’s scraggly, brazen color-pencil drawing of tabloid photos of Amy Winehouse was merely that—before it was shot with a semi-automatic handgun right through the center of the composition, fracturing the glass, ripping the paper, and lodging a bullet in the back of the frame. When this sketch was on display at Ohio State University in 2015, a security officer shot up the gallery before taking his life. Harrison made the decision to keep the bullet hole as a part of the drawing. There’s a visceral horror and amazement to looking through this hole at the imagined site of the shooting. In this one art object, we see distinct layers of sensationalized history: the drug culture of Amy Winehouse’s tabloid world, the insidious spectacle of 2010s gun violence, and the chromatic gradations in between.
Louise Lawler is known for mapping out distance between subject and object in her work, often by photographing the way artworks are installed in museums and observed by visitors. In 1964, the German artist Gerhard Richter painted a magazine photo of the Dresden firebombers in World War II, rendered in his signature cold blur, and called it Mustang Squadron. Lawler took photos of Mustang Squadron installed in a gallery, then contorted them into nearly unrecognizable swirls using digital editing tools to make a series called No Drones (adjusted to fit, distorted for the times). The print in Longer Than the Sky was actually made—scaled and printed in vinyl—to match the dimensions of the wall in the Logan Center. By printing a wall-sized image of a contortion of a photo of an installed painting of another photo of a historical event as captured in a magazine, Lawler mediates our subjectivity more times than we can make sense of, or even count. But all these reifications, contortions, and representations are not merely playful. With each layer of removal, she is marking a leap of cultural distance, and tracking historical continuity, to create a piece of weighted contemporary political critique—about stopping drone use in the Iraq War. It’s difficult to make sense of what we are looking at, and as we try to process the content of this twisting blur, we are forced to think through the historicizing act itself. Forces freeze and distort even the most recognizable historical subjects, rendering them as obscure as Lawler’s photograph. And so, when confronted with the meta-problematic of accessing our history, we are reattuned to our political present.
Deepfake Obama has four eyes and glitches through a rewritten socialist fantasy of his 2009 inaugural speech, on view in the last room of the show. He tells us that “the American dream is too important to let it slowly fade away like the embers of a once blazing fire.” It’s up to us, he says in between too-frequent robotic Obama-esque arm gestures, “to breathe new life into it.” He walks us through a history of leftist policymaking, starting with the workers who began rebuilding the Capitol’s dome the day after the Civil War and the original New Deal goal of a universal living wage. Josh Kline staged Hope and Change in 2015 in the spirit of the 2011 Occupy Wall Street encampments, by using a now-charmingly dated deepfake software projected onto a still image of Obama’s inaugural speech. The piece redeems the desperate economic anxiety of that moment by acting out a wish-fulfillment schema and inserting it, clumsily, back into the historical record. After walking through the show and arriving here, one is attuned to the intentional diachrony of restaging a dead historical moment using an unconvincing ghostly double. Kline carves out a contemporary political imagination in the negative image of the old one, and the result is something emotional and bizarre. He seems to prove Lauren Berlant true when she claims that “[i]t requires a surrealistic affectsphere to counter the one that already exists.”
Jack Whitten’s Bar Code #2, Lateral Shift addresses how socioeconomic continuity can be concealed by symbolic change. Whitten borrows the language of “lateral shift” from the Slovenian philosopher and cultural theorist Slavoj Žižek, who defined it as change taking place within a fundamentally static system. The piece is a mosaic, composed of thick slabs of black-and-white acrylic paint mixed with sparkling metal powders and debris, dried and broken into tiles he called “tesserae,” which are then rearranged and embedded into the canvas. The scene, featuring two differently colored barcode shapes side by side, is an allegorical critique of Obama’s 2008 election: that his win masqueraded as vertical, revolutionary progress, but used this nominal change to preserve an increasingly financialized economy and stratified society. Whitten repurposes material as a play on political repackaging, and the whole composition glitters as a dreamy, pixelated abstraction. He advocates for carefully mapping out historical continuity before erecting monuments to upward growth. In many ways, this “lateral” historical analysis is the critical method of Longer Than the Sky.
Mediation—as it appears in Oppie’s political distancing, Harrison’s bullet hole, Lawler’s contorted painting of a photograph, Kline’s deepfake, and Whitten’s barcodes—frames and reanimates static stories through a kind of necromantic play. Together, these artworks disclose a history of 2008–2016 that actually feels contiguous with the kind of political sociality that would come to define the Trump era, rather than try to hide it. A continuous history-writing allows us to see better, and thus to make authentic aesthetic interventions, toward Berlant’s project of “shap[ing] the sense of immediacy among mass mediated intimate publics in the historical present.” It resolves that awkward double-bind at the root of Obama Center critiques, by redirecting the real nostalgic pride we have in its legacy toward richer imagery—to draw real hope away from purely symbolic change.
Image: Talking Skull, Meta Vaux Warrick Fuller, bronze, 1939.
